Essays/Building

The complete human

Artificial intelligence is closing the gap between what a person can imagine and what one person can make. What remains is the reaching, and something is lost with it.

For most of history, the distance between what a person could imagine and what the same person could make was set by the few crafts one life had time to learn. With artificial intelligence that distance is closing. I find this beautiful and a little sad at once, because when the hand can do almost anything, what is left is the reaching.

The ideal that was open to almost nobody

The Renaissance admired the complete human: one person who paints, builds, composes, trades and writes. It was admired because it was rare. Almost nobody had the time, the teachers or the money to learn more than one craft well, and most people never chose the one they learned.

For everyone else a life was one trade. A person who could draw could not also build the bridge. A person who could sell could not write the music they heard in their head. The imagination was wide and the hands were narrow, and the gap between them was simply the shape of a life.

The grasp has widened

That gap is closing. A person with no training can now make music that sounds finished. A person who has never written code can build software that works. One person can sell to strangers anywhere, buy from anyone, and start what used to need a company with departments. The tools do the parts that used to take years.

I see it in my own work. Much of what I make now is made by agents. I decide what should exist, and they do a great deal of the rest. I have written about why that first decision is the one I cannot hand over. It matters more each year, because the rest keeps getting easier.

There is an old line for this.

Ah, but a man’s reach should exceed his grasp, / Or what’s a heaven for?

It is Robert Browning’s, from “Andrea del Sarto” (1855). It is usually quoted as encouragement. In the poem it reads closer to a confession. The speaker is Andrea del Sarto, the painter called faultless. His hand can do anything he asks of it, and he says so with regret. He has the technique and not the reaching, and he knows which of the two mattered.

What is left when the hand can do almost anything?

I think what is left is the reaching itself. Taste. What one chooses to want. The judgment about what is worth making at all, and the patience to make it well when nothing forces you to.

This is the beautiful part. A person who always heard music and never had the training can now hear it played. A person with an idea for a tool can hold the tool at the end of a week. More people than ever will find out what they would have made. The complete human is no longer an ideal for a few. It is within reach of almost anyone who wants it.

It is also the melancholic part, and I do not want to skip it. Something is being lost. The years of apprenticeship were slow, but they shaped the person who went through them. When we took other people’s campaigns apart at the agency, the analysis itself trained us. The craft was the proof. It showed that someone had cared enough to spend years on one thing. When the result arrives without the years, the proof goes with them.

The excuse goes as well. For most of history one could say: I would have made it, if I had been able to. That sentence was a kind of shelter. It kept the unmade work beautiful, because it was never tested. The shelter is mostly gone now. If the thing is not made, the reason is more often that I did not want it enough, or did not know what I wanted.

That is the warning in Browning’s painter. The danger is not that the tools fail us. It is that they succeed, and we become faultless: able to make anything, with nothing left we are reaching for. A wide grasp with no reach is only production.

I do not know how to reconcile the two feelings, and I am not sure they should be reconciled. I feel fortunate to live at a time when one person can come close to being complete. I also feel the weight of it. There is less standing between me and what I imagine, so more of the result depends on what I am able to imagine.

So I try to keep the reach ahead of the grasp on purpose. I ask what I would make if nothing were hard, and then whether it is worth making. Most days the second question is the harder one. I suspect it is the one that will stay ours.

Back to the essays

Field Notes

A letter from Andrei Hasna on building with AI agents

Subscribe by email

By clicking “Subscribe”, I confirm that I want to get email delivered to my address and agree to Andrei Hasna’s Privacy Policy and Terms.

In each letter

  • New essays on AI agents and the systems behind them
  • What Hasna is building, and why
  • Costs, routing and results from real work
  • What did not work
  • News of the book and the podcast